Oh wow guys seriously, hold it!
I KNOW this topic's kinda old but I rushed through those two pages now and need to say... cool down.
I might be new here and actually shouldn't bug in into something that totally isn't my piece of cake, but the real problem here is that you guys don't feel like cooperating with each other in one or two points.
Mitsu, though you apologized towards Rapid and Pop you really need to keep your coolness. Insulting people won't help you at all, it'll make things even more worse for you since *you're* the one who plays the "a******" role in that matter. Using the "You don't have a XYZ OC!" line won't do you any good just because Pop brought up something that made your blood boil. Everyone's free to let their thoughts ride. Pointing out that Pop doesn't have an OC = No problem. Insulting him at the end = Big nope. Small things like that can break sympathy pretty easy, no matter if you're acting totally different in Real Life. Users will see the MitsuKoshi that loves to insult people rather than the MitsuKoshi you are in Real Life. Never forget that.
The RP-Plots I've read so far are... meh. Neither good nor bad, but not overthought either.
You see, making Cross-Over RP's are hard to manage and really take a good sense of how to play it, especially when you try to cross two franchises that:
1. Don't share certain elements that could make a good story out of it
2. Not many people know because they (probably) never played it/never had interest in it
Pokémon is a very popular franchise, but it makes no sense playing it when humans aren't involved when you're aiming for the main franchise of it. If you're going into something more Anthropomorphic related, like that the Pokémon are 'the humans', I'd place my bets on a "Pokémon Mystery Dungeon"-styled system or that the Pokémon act like total normal humans a la Rocket Knight/Star Fox/What-do-I-know. The real key is to find a way to place the Rocket Knight characters into this whole Cross-Over. What roles would they play? What are their goals? How'd they look like if physical appearance has to be overworked? That's a lot of things everyone need to think of as well, not just only the plot.
Look, I don't try to be a smartass with all this yackering, but I have a lot of experiences with all kinds of RPs and Cross-Overs aren't really my thing because those I've seen so far ended up in a desaster. I don't want to say they're horrible, but gaining mostly not so good experiences with them I try to stay away from them. If you guys still love to do any kind of Cross-Over, feel free to and don't mind my twisted sight about them.
If it's going to be a RK-related RP there's actually a lot you people can do, it's just a matter as of how you people come along with each other. If there's one thing I totally dislike, it's the 'letting out my anger towards someone within the RP' stuff. Never do this kind of sh*t, otherwise you'll ruin the fun for everyone. It's not only for RK-related RPs, it's for *all* kinds of RPs. I'm sure people know that but I still highlight this issue since sometimes people forget about it nonetheless (if the rage is over 9000).
Let's see. We have a lot of Original/Fan Characters for the Rocket Knights and the Black Knights... or Dark Knights if you people prefer. It *seems* to be possible to play the Official Characters (Sparkster, Axel Gear, King Zephyrus, Princess Sherry, Princess Cherry, probably even Princess Flora, Devligus Devotindos, General Sweinhart, Emperor Gedol, Paerie, Generalissimo Lioness, General Wolfenheim, Emperor Ulfgar, Mifune Sanjulo/Sanjuurou, Sparkster's Wife, Sparkster's Son...), so there's actually a bunch of people that can be played. Fine 'n' dandy so far! Actually you people have good opportunities to start a big RP.
But let me ask you all one question:
What are you aiming for?
Everyone has their own ideas, stories, characters and so on and so on, and it's pretty hard to let those flow into one big RolePlay. It also seems like that some Users don't come along too well with each other and some Users left this place - which is a real shame. Both of those points.
Taking "Rocket Knights: Raise of the Black Knights" from Kohaku as an example. This story is very well overthought and has tons of good ideas. Users wanted to join and sadly it burned down faster than expected. I haven't read all of it now, but from what I saw on the last page and the beginning page... I was very curious about the whole situation between Kaji, his family, Kohaku... the overall plot. It was very well written, even the parts with the two hedgehog brothers and Sparkster's family, but the thing that was killing it for me was the Mr. Saturn thing. It's a downer if characters from a totally different franchise crashes into a plot that focuses on Rocket Knight only, nearly ruining the good readable effort that was done until this certain point.
Look, I don't like to criticize others, especially when I know that certain ideas shouldn't be taking too seriously, but out of all the things that could have happened, it's Mr. Saturn from EarthBound/Mother. It's like there's a damn intense fight going on, someone got blown into pieces and all in a sudden Steve Urcle pops out of nowhere saying "Did I do that?". It's killing a certain atmosphere. That's how I felt when I was reaching the Mr. Saturn appearance.
In fact it's a bit unfair from my side being harsh on this RP though I haven't read all of it, but if there's a Rocket Knight RP going on please, don't throw in random characters from other franchises *exept* the rules of the RP allow it. No matter if you're an newbee or expert in RPs, this doesn't excuse it when the rules say "Rocket Knight-based characters only". I haven't seen any rule so far but I guess it should be clear to everyone that in a Rocket Knight RP there's only Rocket Knight-based characters. Still I wished that "Rise of the Black Knights" will be continued by you guys.
I'm sorry for being harsh on you MitsuKoshi, I apologize at that point and I hope you can forgive me. I don't want to be any offensive to you at all, but I'm pointing out a thing that was quite out of place. I still give credit to Kohaku and Jake that they played along with your Mr. Saturn appearance rather than ignoring it totally. This is what I call good companions. Be proud of them. Also you played great as well considering the little rant about the Mr. Saturn cameo. Just because I didn't liked it doesn't mean you're a bad player
Enough of this long talk. I hope there's still some way to let this Forum be more active again so people can enjoy their RPs. It'll be such a big waste of effort letting this forum die. If this forum is getting a bit more life I'd be happy to RP with you guys since I'm pretty sure that everyone can work on a decent plot for an RP of any kind.